Pivoting Beyond Higher Ed (Exploring Career Pivots - Pt. 2)

Hey Professors,

In my last podcast episode, which was Episode 63, I shared some practical tips with you on how to consider a possible career pivot within higher education. 

I talked about 5 different types of pivots that you could make within higher ed—like:

  1. Keeping the same role, but moving to a different institution
  2. Staying at your current institution, but shifting into a different role
  3. Upskilling in a new area at your current university, with the idea of possibly moving to a different one later on
  4. Moving from full-time to part-time status
  5. Trying to imagine how to redefine your current role at your institution.

Now, that wasn’t an exhaustive list of the categories of pivots that you could make within higher education—but just a sampling of what may be feasible.

But what if you’ve thought through these different scenarios and nothing is really resonating for you?

How do you begin to prepare for the possibility of a career beyond academia? Especially if you’ve invested over 15 years in higher education, thinking that this was the only career pathway for you?

If you’re stumped, then this episode might be a good starting point for you.

In this 64th episode of the Rise with Clarity Podcast, I’m going to share some of my own story with my career pivot out of academia into a field that is higher ed adjacent: higher ed coaching and consulting.

And then I’m going to draw out the importance of mindset as well as offer you 5 reflective questions that may help you to take the first steps in determining what your pivot plans might be. This is Part 2 of an “Exploring Career Pivot Series.” 

I’ve talked a little bit about this on the podcast before, but I thought I would share more about my journey in terms of how I came to take the first steps with my career pivot exploration.

I first began actively contemplating a career pivot in 2021, during the pandemic. At that time, I was an Associate Professor and I had been tenured for 2 years. Unfortunately, because I was in a toxic and dysfunctional work environment that did not appear to show signs of improvement, I felt really stuck. 

One possibility for me was to stay until age 50 and to retire early. So, I did consider staying at my institution, like I had talked about on the previous podcast episode 63, which is about pivoting within higher education.

But because I sensed that I had many years of work life ahead of me, I wanted to consider what other career pathways could look like for me.

At the beginning of 2021, I was teaching full-time. Because we were still teaching online and I had more time because I was not commuting in LA traffic, I was able to explore two potential pivots: that of arts administration and professional coaching.

I selected arts administration because I had previously worked in arts management in South Korea in the early 2000s. And because I had also curated many events (academic talks, performances, and conferences) in both of my jobs on the tenure track. I also greatly enjoyed this kind of work and I felt that I was pretty good at it.

So while I was teaching full time, I enrolled in the Executive Program in Arts and Culture Strategy offered by the National Arts Strategies and the University of Pennsylvania. This was an 8-month online course that was designed for cultivating leaders in the nonprofit arts and culture sector.

At the same time that I took this course and was teaching full-time, I also followed one curiosity of mine. And that second path of exploration was that of coaching. 

I reached out to one acquaintance of mine—who I will forever be grateful to—and I asked if they would be interested in working with me as a coach. Mind you, I had no coaching credential, no coaching experience, and no training at the time.

But I did have about a decade of experience of working very closely, 1-to-1 with graduate students and undergraduate students in advising sessions and independent studies at 2 different R1 universities. I always felt that I was well-suited for 1-1 work, and that I enjoyed seeing my students develop both as people and as scholars and professionals over time.

So I took a strength of mine and explored what that could look like in a different form—which was coaching. And I loved it. I found that coaching was really interesting, meaningful, and gratifying. 

By the fall of 2021, I had completed the Arts and Culture Strategy course. And, also, through word of mouth, I had enrolled 6 coaching clients without any social media presence or a website, since I had to keep it on the DL.

So at this point, I had gathered information about 2 very different pathways. And I needed to do some honest assessments.

I realized that with arts administration—the first area of exploration—I definitely had the skill set to move back into this world, but for some reason, my heart just wasn’t in it at the time. But with coaching, I felt that there was a lot for me to continue to learn and also a lot for me to offer.

Through this exploration process, I also discovered that there was a need for this kind of service—especially for women of color faculty—which gave me the sense that there was financial viability for this kind of pathway.

This was important for me, as someone who is very risk averse.

So, I want to stop here for now. If you’re interested in hearing more about my journey into higher ed coaching, please listen to Episode 32. But for today, I want to draw out a few things from my story here that may be useful for you if you are in that very beginning stage of contemplating your pivot.

And so much of this has to do with your mindset.

Adopting a Growth Vs. a Fixed Mindset Towards Your Career Pivot

I think what made it easier for me to reflect on and to take the first steps towards my pivot: was to ultimately shift my mindset—which to be honest, was pretty fixed and locked into staying in my tenured faculty position b/c that seemed like the most prudent and financially sensible thing to do.

This work on mindset, in combination with getting more clarity on my core values (which I’ve talked about in Episode 19) gave me the push that I needed in order to take the initiative to research my plans B and C with more depth.

Now the reasons for why you may be considering a career pivot beyond academia will be unique to you and your situation.

Obviously, there may be external factors like toxic work environments, institutional restructuring and closures, political pressures, or tenure denials and dismissals that are pushing you to look for careers outside of higher education. I want to acknowledge that this can be an incredibly difficult and emotionally fraught way to start your pivot.

But also, there might be some personal factors, too. Like wanting to have more financial stability, wanting to have more control over where you live or your schedule, and also doing something that really lights you up.

Maybe you’re ready to throw in the towel when it comes to teaching and grading in this age of AI.

Or maybe there’s something that you’ve always wanted to pursue, but didn’t get to because you got locked in to the tenure track.

Researching a possible career pivot can be a way of exploring what you are curious about and/or leaning into what you are already good at—but thinking about it in a new form.

5 Reflective Questions to Help You with Your Pivot Exploration

So here are 5 reflective questions to help you with this mindset piece, especially if you are in that stuck place of not knowing where to even begin with your pivot exploration.

1) How would you define yourself professionally beyond your academic title, your discipline, or your publications, and are you open to expressing your professional identity differently?

2) What skills do you have that you are proud of, and how would you communicate that value to an audience outside of academia?

3) What are you moving towards vs. leaving behind in your life?

4) What do you want to learn in this next chapter of your professional career?

5) What feels like a realistic and incremental first step for you in your pivot exploration and can you set a goal for that in the next month?

In my next episode, I’m going to share about a framework on pivoting that could be a tool that you use in these types of career pivot explorations. So please stay tuned for that.

I also wanted to mention that I do offer support to faculty who are considering career pivots both within and beyond higher education. Currently, I’m offering a $100 discount on my 90-minute strategy sessions for the month of November. These sessions could be great in confidentially brainstorming together with me what 1 possible pivot could be and determining what your next steps are.

Feel free to check out my Strategy Session on my website and also reach out to me at Katherine at RisewithClarity.com. You can reserve a Strategy session by the end of this month and then bank it for later.

Also, do feel free to check out my other podcast episodes for other resources on career pivoting, which I will link to at the end of the written transcript for this episode.